A white background with a few lines on it

Protect What Matters Most

 Independent. Local. Trusted since 1979.

Your Peace of mind starts here

Coverage That Cares About What You Value Most

At Anderson Insurance, we believe insurance is more than a policy—it’s a promise. Since 1979, we’ve helped people across Circleville and surrounding communities protect what matters most with affordable coverage and honest, personal guidance.


Whether you're insuring your home, car, health, business, or land, we make the process simple, never rushed, and always centered on your needs. We proudly serve Chillicothe, Lancaster, and towns throughout Fairfield, Ross, and Fayette Counties.

A black car is driving down the street in front of a large building.

Our Insurance Services

HOme insurance

Your home is more than a place to live, it’s where your life unfolds. Our homeowners insurance helps protect your house, belongings, and peace of mind with flexible, affordable coverage tailored to your needs. It’s protection that fits your home, your budget, and your future.

Learn More

Automobile Insurance

From your daily commute to weekend drives, we make sure you’re protected behind the wheel. Our auto insurance covers cars, trucks, RVs, and motorcycles with flexible, affordable plans that reflect how you drive and what you value. It’s coverage that moves with you, mile after mile.

Learn More

Health & Medicare Insurance

Healthcare shouldn't be hard to manage. We help you explore health plans and Medicare options, simplify the paperwork, and understand your benefits. Our team makes it easy to get the care you need, with coverage that supports your health, your family, and your future.

Learn More

HOme insurance

Your home is more than a place to live, it’s where your life unfolds. Our homeowners insurance helps protect your house, belongings, and peace of mind with flexible, affordable coverage tailored to your needs.

Learn More

Automobile Insurance

From your daily commute to weekend drives, we make sure you’re protected behind the wheel. Our auto insurance covers cars, trucks, RVs, and motorcycles with flexible, affordable plans that reflect how you drive and what you value. It’s coverage that moves with you, mile after mile.

Learn More

Health & Medicare Insurance

Healthcare shouldn't be hard to manage. We help you explore health plans and Medicare options, simplify the paperwork, and understand your benefits. Our team makes it easy to get the care you need, with coverage that supports your health, your family, and your future.

Learn More

Life Insurance

If you owe someone or love someone, life insurance is one of the most important choices you can make. We tailor policies to meet your goals—protecting your income, legacy, and long-term security with coverage that’s personal, thoughtful, and made to last.


Learn More

Farm Insurance

Your land, equipment, and livelihood deserve protection you can count on. Our farm insurance policies are designed to meet the risks you face every day—customized for family farms and operations across Ohio with coverage that’s practical, local, and built to last.


Learn More

COmmercial Insurance

We help protect your business from the ground up with commercial insurance that covers property, liability, employees, and more. Whether you own a small shop or manage a growing team, our coverage adapts to your needs with real-world protection and responsive service.



Learn More

Life Insurance

If you owe someone or love someone, life insurance is one of the most important choices you can make. We tailor policies to meet your goals—protecting your income, legacy, and long-term security with coverage that’s personal, thoughtful, and made to last.


Learn More

Farm Insurance

Your land, equipment, and livelihood deserve protection you can count on. Our farm insurance policies are designed to meet the risks you face every day—customized for family farms and operations across Ohio with coverage that’s practical, local, and built to last.





Learn More

COmmercial Insurance

We help protect your business from the ground up with commercial insurance that covers property, liability, employees, and more. Whether you own a small shop or manage a growing team, our coverage adapts to your needs with real-world protection and responsive service.



Learn More

Why Choose Anderson Insurance

We’re an independent agency that works for you. Since 1979, Anderson Insurance has served families and businesses in Circleville, Chillicothe, and throughout Pickaway County with trusted coverage and service that puts people first.

A check mark in a circle on a white background.

Access to respected, top-rated insurance providers

A check mark in a circle on a white background.

Coverage designed around your life and goals

A check mark in a circle on a white background.

Local agents who know you and show up for you

See What Our Clients Are Saying

Very nice people. Go see Polly she's wonderful :)

– Adventure H.

By far the best experience i've ever had with ANY insurance company i've dealt with. Nedra is the best! Thanks again!

– Jacob C.

Very nice people. Go see Polly she's wonderful :)

– Adventure H.

By far the best experience i've ever had with ANY insurance company i've dealt with. Nedra is the best! Thanks again!

– Jacob C.

See Coverage Options

Let’s Talk About Your Coverage

We’re ready to help—whether you’re shopping for your first policy or reviewing coverage you’ve had for years. We’re here to walk you through it all in plain, clear terms. Reach out today to get started.

Start the Conversation